Tokina RMC 17mm f/3.5 - Review / Lab Test Report - Analysis
Lens Reviews -
Wednesday, 26 December 2007 04:26
Page 2 of 2
The Tokina exhibits a fairly pronounced degree of barrel distortion (~2.5%). This isn't bad
for a lens in the focal length class and it is nothing special either.
The chart above has a real-world size of about 120x80cm.
As mentioned the Tokina is a full format lens so it has a sweet-spot advantage when used on
an APS-C DSLR. However, at f/3.5 the amount of vignetting is still fairly heavy (~1.14EV).
Stopping down to f/5.6 and beyond reduces the problem to a manageable degree.
The Tokina was able to surprise with a pretty decent resolution characteristic in the
MTF lab. At f/3.5 the center and border is already on a very good level whereas the
extreme corners are quite soft. Stopping down increases the quality and the peak
performance is reached at f/8 with an excellent center resolution and very good
borders and extreme corners. The Tokina can also keep this level at f/11 without any
big impact from diffraction effects.
While this sound pretty good it is also worth to mention that the contrast level is
very low at f/3.5. I'd say that the color rendition is also a bit off the
The lab-type tests did not show any significant problems
but some field shots (infinity focus) showed a rather pronounced softness on the left
hand side of the image field so the age of the lens obviously took its toll somewhere.
Below is a simplified summary of the formal findings. The chart shows line widths
per picture height (LW/PH) which can be taken as a measure for sharpness.
If you want to know more about the MTF50 figures you may check out the corresponding
Chromatic Aberrations (CAs)
Lateral chromatic aberrations (color shadows at harsh contrast transitions) are a
significant problem at large aperture settings - at f/3.5 and f/5.6 the CAs
reach an average width up to ~2px at the image borders. At f/8 and f/11 the
problem is reduced and not overly disturbing anymore.
The Tokina RMC 17mm f/3.5 may be an oldie but it is still a fairly high
resolution lens especially when stopped down a bit. At f/3.5 the contrast
level is very low and the amount of vignetting is quite pronounced
so it is a good idea to avoid this setting. The lens shows a high
degree of barrel distortions but if we put this into context this is a
quite normal behavior in this focal length class. The build quality is
exceptional but using such an old lens on the Pentax K10D is a bit
cumbersome. The Tokina had its time but frankly the Pentax DA 16-45mm f/4 ED AL
(for instance) is a better choice.